Bay Shore, NY Commercial Investment Properties for Sale

Explore commercial real estate investment properties for sale in Bay Shore, New York Market population: 28K. Explore income-producing properties with verified cap rates...

No exact matches found. Showing similar properties in New York.

2 properties found

Investor Pitch Deck

Don’t just search properties. See why investors choose REI Capital.

Before you compare every deal alone, download the REI Capital investment pitch and see our growth story, strategy, and next-step materials.

View Properties Access Investment Materials

📊 Average Cap Rate For Bay Shore NY Properties: 6.86%

⭐ Featured

190 Manhattan Ave, Buffalo, NY â€“ Prime Multifamily Investment with 7.56% Cap Rate

$6,500,000

Buffalo Multifamily

Discover a compelling investment in Buffaloâ€™s vibrant market with this 65,000-square-foot garden-style apartment prope...

Cap Rate 7.56%

NOI $491,400

Size 65,000 SF

Save

📊 Avg Property Tax Rate For Bay Shore NY Properties: 4.3450%

⭐ Featured

Prime Buffalo Multifamily Investment: 12-Unit Apartment Building with 6.16% Cap Rate

$1,750,000

Buffalo Multifamily

Discover a compelling multifamily investment opportunity in Buffalo, NY. This 12-unit apartment building, priced at $1,7...

Cap Rate 6.16%

NOI $107,842

Size 8,640 SF

Save

Investor Questions For Bay Shore NY

Common questions from investors exploring commercial real estate in Bay Shore NY.

What is the overall investment potential of Bay Shore, NY? +

The 8.8% poverty rate and $69,597 median household income in Bay Shore suggest a relatively stable market, while the 24.1% foreign born rate and diverse top ethnicities, including White, Hispanic, and White Non-Hispanic, indicate a culturally rich and potentially resilient community. With a median age of 36.6 and 85% of the population having health insurance, the area appears to have a solid foundation for attracting and retaining residents. Additionally, the top industries and employed population of 14,248 contribute to the local economy's stability.

How does the commute time and transportation infrastructure impact the rental market in Bay Shore? +

The average commute time of 29 minutes in Bay Shore, combined with a strong public transit system, suggests that residents have reliable access to employment and amenities, making the area more attractive to renters. This, paired with the median property value of $283,400 and median property taxes of $6,800, indicates a relatively stable and affordable housing market. The 0.414 GINI coefficient also implies a moderate level of income inequality, which could impact rental yields.

What role does ethnic diversity play in shaping the local real estate market? +

The diverse ethnic makeup of Bay Shore, with White, Hispanic, and White Non-Hispanic populations, contributes to a vibrant and dynamic community, which can drive demand for housing and local businesses. This diversity, combined with the area's relatively low poverty rate of 8.8% and high health insurance coverage, suggests a strong and stable tenant base. Furthermore, the top industries in the area are likely to attract a skilled and diverse workforce, supporting the local real estate market.

How do the local economy and employment opportunities influence the investment potential of Bay Shore? +

The employed population of 14,248 and median household income of $69,597 in Bay Shore indicate a relatively strong local economy, with top industries likely driving job growth and stability. This, paired with the area's moderate income inequality, as represented by the 0.414 GINI coefficient, suggests that investors may find opportunities in both affordable and higher-end housing segments. The 24.1% foreign born rate also implies a potential for international investment and cultural exchange.

What are the key factors to consider when assessing the quality of life and market stability in Bay Shore? +

When evaluating the quality of life and market stability in Bay Shore, investors should consider the average commute time, health insurance coverage, and poverty rate, which collectively suggest a relatively stable and affordable community. The median age of 36.6, diverse ethnicities, and top industries also contribute to a dynamic and resilient local economy. Additionally, the median property value and property taxes provide insight into the housing market's affordability and potential for appreciation.

Bay Shore NY Real Estate & City Facts

Key facts and real estate information about Bay Shore NY.

What are some of the best neighborhoods to live in Bay Shore? +

Some of the best neighborhoods to live in Bay Shore include Sagtikos Pkwy, Chicago Park, Brightwaters, and West Bay Shore. These areas are known for being safe and having beautiful homes.

What are some fun things to do in Bay Shore? +

There are plenty of fun things to do in Bay Shore, such as visiting the Boulton Center for the Performing Arts, exploring Gardiner County Park, and checking out the Sagtikos Manor. You can also grab a drink or bite to eat at one of the many bars and restaurants on Main Street or by the marina.

What is the food scene like in Bay Shore? +

The food scene in Bay Shore is diverse and exciting, with a range of restaurants serving everything from fresh seafood to handcrafted cocktails. Some popular spots include The LakeHouse, Tula Kitchen, Tullulah's, and Nicky's on the Bay. There are also plenty of great food trucks and casual eateries to try.

What are the pros and cons of living in Bay Shore? +

The pros of living in Bay Shore include its beautiful beaches, vibrant downtown area, and diverse community. However, some cons include the potential for traffic and crowds during peak season, as well as the need for a car to get around. Overall, Bay Shore is a great place to live for those who want a mix of relaxation and activity.

Is Bay Shore a good place to live? +

Yes, Bay Shore is a good place to live for many people. It offers a unique blend of small-town charm and big-city amenities, and its location on the Great South Bay makes it perfect for outdoor enthusiasts. While it may have its drawbacks, the pros of living in Bay Shore far outweigh the cons for many residents.

Bay Shore, NY Commercial Investment Properties for Sale

Don’t just search properties. See why investors choose REI Capital.

📊 Average Cap Rate For Bay Shore NY Properties: 6.86%

190 Manhattan Ave, Buffalo, NY â€“ Prime Multifamily Investment with 7.56% Cap Rate

📊 Avg Property Tax Rate For Bay Shore NY Properties: 4.3450%

Prime Buffalo Multifamily Investment: 12-Unit Apartment Building with 6.16% Cap Rate

Investor Questions For Bay Shore NY

Bay Shore NY Real Estate & City Facts

Explore More Opportunities

Cities in NY

Investment Opportunities by City

Property Types by City

Bay Shore, NY Investment Filters

High Cap Rate - Bay Shore, NY

Medium Cap Rate - Bay Shore, NY

Low Cap Rate - Bay Shore, NY

High NOI - Bay Shore, NY

Medium NOI - Bay Shore, NY

Premium Properties - Bay Shore, NY

Affordable Deals - Bay Shore, NY

Mid-Range Properties - Bay Shore, NY

High Yield Deals - Bay Shore, NY

Best Value Investments - Bay Shore, NY