Middle Island, NY Commercial Investment Properties for Sale

Explore commercial real estate investment properties for sale in Middle Island, New York Market population: 10K. Explore income-producing properties with verified cap rates...

No exact matches found. Showing similar properties in New York.

2 properties found

Investor Pitch Deck

Don’t just search properties. See why investors choose REI Capital.

Before you compare every deal alone, download the REI Capital investment pitch and see our growth story, strategy, and next-step materials.

View Properties Access Investment Materials

📊 Average Cap Rate For Middle Island NY Properties: 6.86%

⭐ Featured

190 Manhattan Ave, Buffalo, NY â€“ Prime Multifamily Investment with 7.56% Cap Rate

$6,500,000

Buffalo Multifamily

Discover a compelling investment in Buffaloâ€™s vibrant market with this 65,000-square-foot garden-style apartment prope...

Cap Rate 7.56%

NOI $491,400

Size 65,000 SF

Save

📊 Avg Property Tax Rate For Middle Island NY Properties: 1.4500%

⭐ Featured

Prime Buffalo Multifamily Investment: 12-Unit Apartment Building with 6.16% Cap Rate

$1,750,000

Buffalo Multifamily

Discover a compelling multifamily investment opportunity in Buffalo, NY. This 12-unit apartment building, priced at $1,7...

Cap Rate 6.16%

NOI $107,842

Size 8,640 SF

Save

Investor Questions For Middle Island NY

Common questions from investors exploring commercial real estate in Middle Island NY.

What's the overall investment potential of Middle Island, NY? +

Middle Island, NY offers a stable investment market with a median household income of $69,406, a relatively low poverty rate of 10.2%, and a high health insurance coverage rate of 95.7%, indicating a reliable tenant base. The top industries, including Public Administration and Manufacturing, contribute to a diverse economy, while the median property value of $273,500 and median property taxes of $3,136 provide a balanced housing market. With a commute time of 32.9 minutes and top commute methods including driving and carpooling, the area's infrastructure supports a convenient lifestyle.

How does the local economy impact real estate investment in Middle Island? +

The local economy in Middle Island, driven by top industries such as Public Administration, Wholesale Trade, and Manufacturing, supports a median household income of $69,406 and an employed population of 4,731. This economic stability, combined with a poverty rate of 10.2% and a high health insurance coverage rate of 95.7%, suggests a strong potential for rental income and property appreciation. The area's ethnic diversity, with a mix of White, White Non-Hispanic, and Black populations, also contributes to a vibrant community.

What are the key factors to consider when evaluating property investment in Middle Island? +

When evaluating property investment in Middle Island, consider the median property value of $273,500, median property taxes of $3,136, and a homeownership rate of 73.4%, which indicate a relatively stable housing market. Additionally, the area's average commute time of 32.9 minutes, top commute methods, and health insurance coverage rate of 95.7% provide insights into the quality of life and potential for long-term rentals. The GINI coefficient of 0.373 also suggests a relatively equal distribution of income, contributing to a stable tenant base.

How does the demographic profile of Middle Island impact real estate investment? +

The demographic profile of Middle Island, with a median age of 42.6, top ethnicities including White and Black populations, and a foreign-born rate that is not applicable, suggests a diverse and established community. The median household income of $69,406 and employed population of 4,731 also indicate a strong economic foundation. With a poverty rate of 10.2% and health insurance coverage rate of 95.7%, the area's demographic profile supports a reliable and stable tenant base, making it an attractive location for real estate investment.

What are the prospects for long-term property appreciation in Middle Island? +

The prospects for long-term property appreciation in Middle Island are supported by a median property value of $273,500, a relatively low poverty rate of 10.2%, and a high health insurance coverage rate of 95.7%. The area's diverse economy, driven by top industries such as Public Administration and Manufacturing, and its convenient commute time of 32.9 minutes, also contribute to a stable and growing housing market. With a homeownership rate of 73.4% and a GINI coefficient of 0.373, the potential for long-term property appreciation in Middle Island is promising, making it an attractive location for real estate investors.

Middle Island NY Real Estate & City Facts

Key facts and real estate information about Middle Island NY.

What are some of the best neighborhoods to live in Middle Island? +

Some of the best neighborhoods to live in Middle Island include the northwest parts of the city, which tend to be more desired, and the southeast regions, which offer more affordable homes. Specifically, neighborhoods like Middle Island Cleaner, Ridge, and areas near the William Floyd Parkway are known for their cleanliness, safety, and family-friendly atmosphere.

What are some fun things to do in Middle Island? +

There are plenty of fun things to do in Middle Island, including visiting Cathedral Pines County Park, Bartlett Pond Park, and Regency Forest Pet Memorial Park. You can also explore the Setauket-Port Jefferson Station Greenway Trail, Glacier Ridge Preserve, and Mount Sinai Harbor. Additionally, the nearby city of Port Jefferson offers annual events like the Belmont Stakes and an Oyster Festival.

What is the food scene like in Middle Island? +

The food scene in Middle Island is diverse and offers a range of options, including Mediterranean cuisine at restaurants like Ada Mediterranean Cuisine Grill and Turkish Mediterranean Cuisine. You can also find Italian food at Lombardi's Italian Restaurant, Chinese food at Good Wok Restaurant, and American diner fare at Mid Island Diner. There are also plenty of great food trucks and other eateries to explore.

What are the pros and cons of living in Middle Island? +

The pros of living in Middle Island include its peaceful and family-friendly neighborhoods, affordable housing options, and access to outdoor recreational activities. However, some cons include the fact that it's a relatively small town with limited entertainment options, and traffic can be a issue in certain areas. Additionally, some residents have noted that the town can feel a bit sleepy and lacking in nightlife.

Is Middle Island a good place to live? +

Overall, Middle Island can be a great place to live for those who value a peaceful and family-friendly atmosphere, outdoor recreation, and a relatively affordable cost of living. While it may not offer the same level of excitement and entertainment as larger cities, it provides a comfortable and safe environment for residents to enjoy. As with any town, it's essential to weigh the pros and cons and consider individual priorities and preferences when deciding whether Middle Island is the right fit.

Middle Island, NY Commercial Investment Properties for Sale

Don’t just search properties. See why investors choose REI Capital.

📊 Average Cap Rate For Middle Island NY Properties: 6.86%

190 Manhattan Ave, Buffalo, NY â€“ Prime Multifamily Investment with 7.56% Cap Rate

📊 Avg Property Tax Rate For Middle Island NY Properties: 1.4500%

Prime Buffalo Multifamily Investment: 12-Unit Apartment Building with 6.16% Cap Rate

Investor Questions For Middle Island NY

Middle Island NY Real Estate & City Facts

Explore More Opportunities

Cities in NY

Investment Opportunities by City

Property Types by City

Middle Island, NY Investment Filters

High Cap Rate - Middle Island, NY

Medium Cap Rate - Middle Island, NY

Low Cap Rate - Middle Island, NY

High NOI - Middle Island, NY

Medium NOI - Middle Island, NY

Premium Properties - Middle Island, NY

Affordable Deals - Middle Island, NY

Mid-Range Properties - Middle Island, NY

High Yield Deals - Middle Island, NY

Best Value Investments - Middle Island, NY